Recruitee now works with thumb ratings (strong yes, yes, not sure, or no) and the old star rating has been phased out. You can learn more about how to make detailed candidate evaluations or make quick candidate evaluations.
However, if you previously worked with the star rating, it is still possible to view them in Recruitee:
1. Go to a candidate's profile > Click the Evaluation tab.
2. Click the Completed tab.
3. Scroll down to the Star rating section. Here you will see all of your team's previous star ratings for the candidate.